Canada 'associate member' label deepens split between von der Leyen and Merz
A dispute over what to call the EU's future relationship with Canada has worsened tensions between Brussels and Berlin, four diplomats told Politico.
A disagreement over what to call the European Union's future relationship with Canada is widening a split between European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, according to Politico, which cited four diplomats.
The dispute centres on von der Leyen's proposal to make Canada an "associate member" of the EU. Politico reported that tensions grew after she promoted the phrase at a summit in Montreal. That came just hours after a German-led push had removed the wording from a joint statement approved by the 27 EU capitals.
Merz had earlier suggested "associate member" as a status for Ukraine while it works toward full EU membership. Politico reported that the idea was widely rejected, including by Kyiv, and that officials in Berlin see von der Leyen's use of the term for Canada as a rebuke of the chancellor's plan.
According to two EU diplomats cited by Politico, the problem lies in the details. Von der Leyen's version of the status, as applied to Canada, would go to a country that could never fully join the EU. That rules it out as a stepping stone for Ukraine. One diplomat told the outlet that "Germany had different plans for associate membership" and still does.
Both sides say they agree on substance. Commission chief spokesperson Paula Pinho said Berlin and Brussels share the same basic goals on EU-Canada ties. A German diplomat told Politico:
“There is no difference in substance. We both committed to form a unique partnership that we don't have with any other country outside the European Union.”
Why it matters: Politico describes the label fight as part of a broader divide over how the EU should be run. Berlin has said it will not approve the Commission's proposed long-term budget of around €2 trillion unless "hundreds of billions" are cut. Von der Leyen's proposal for a European Security Council has also failed to gain support in Germany, which has backed a separate format with France and the UK on sensitive Ukraine matters.
Jan Techau, head of Germany for the Eurasia Group, told Politico: "There is this institutional dilemma between Brussels and Berlin." He described the question of whether the EU should be driven by its common institutions or by national governments as, in many ways, "unresolvable."
What is not known: It is not clear how or whether the dispute will be settled. Politico reported that Berlin repeated its opposition at a meeting of EU ambassadors on Wednesday, while a person familiar with von der Leyen's thinking said she has no intention of dropping the label. A representative for Merz did not respond to Politico's request for comment. The diplomats quoted in the report spoke on condition of anonymity, and this account rests on that single report.